Pulse pumps will work on some four strokes, the Briggs and Stratton V twins use them. The problem with a VW is that they run a negative pressure crankcase I think, rather than an open breather vented system like the B&S.
If I remember correctly, VWs use a system a bit like the BMW boxer bike engine, with a one way valve on the crankcase breather that lets air out but not in. By running the crankcase at a partial vacuum the pumping losses are reduced quite a bit, plus the chance of venting oil via the breather is much reduced. It also tends to stop oil leaks when the engine is running.
The first few times the engine turns over each time you start it effectively gets the crankcase down to vacuum and is probably enough to stop a pulse pump springing back to pump (the vacuum pulls the diaphragm back, against a spring, and the spring then provides a near-constant pressure on the pump stroke).
Jeremy |